For 15 years, fans have analyzed every detail to clarify what happened to Tony Soprano (James Gandolfini) in the final seconds of “The Sopranos.” Not a line or a picture from the 86 episodes has escaped scrutiny in an attempt to decipher the abrupt transition to black. The series’ reluctant creator, David Chase, has been unwilling to give unambiguous answers to the open-ended ending – despite fans’ frustration. Ideally, everyone should embrace Chase’s boldness and the disturbing mystique surrounding the final minutes of Holsten’s in the “Made in America” finale.
The season focused heavily on mortality, making it likely that Tony met his fate while eating onion rings. A specific remark from Paulie (Tony Sirico) may have solved the riddle without anyone noticing.
Read: These LEGO x Nike shoes look amazing, but there’s a catch
<h3 class="wp-block-heading">”The Sopranos” warns of death repeatedly
As a series about organized crime and its brutal consequences, death is a constant threat in “The Sopranos.” Characters are killed off by their own or rival gangs, and everyone lives with the feeling that everything could collapse at any moment. For Tony Soprano, it can come as a shot in the back of the head – or worse: a knock on the door from the FBI.
In Season 7, Chase and the screenwriters began to undermine the “anti-hero’s” sense by showing how these mafia members reflected on their own moral corruption and empty capitalist ambitions. They could feel death approaching. In the season premiere “Soprano Home Movies,” Bobby Bacala (Steve Schirripa), the most innocent in the family, speculates that “you probably don’t even hear it when it happens” when you’re faced with a gun. In “Stage 5”, Silvio (Steven Van Zandt) sees a New York boss being shot during dinner – without hearing the shots.
Paulie’s line in the finale suggests that life and death coexist
During Bobby’s funeral meal in the finale, Paulie sits at the table with Meadow (Jamie-Lynn Sigler), A.J. (Robert Iler), and other young family members and says:
“In the midst of death, we are alive. Or is it the opposite?”
Meadow corrects him, but the line – taken from a Gregorian hymn – means everything and nothing at the same time. Paulie was known for his seemingly profound, but often meaningless, life assessments. Earlier in the series, his sayings were funny and naïve, but in the finale he comes across as superficial and disillusioned.
“Made in America” is not about tying loose ends, but about accepting fate in a brutal world. After Silvio and Bobby are eliminated in the penultimate episode, “Blue Comet,” Paulie is the last in Tony’s inner circle remaining. Tony offers him a lucrative captaincy position, but Paulie – still shaky after a black cat stared at a picture of the late Christopher (Michael Imperioli) – hesitates. He knows that everyone who has led this crew has met a cruel end.
Paulie’s development is one of the series’ most underrated triumphs. From comic relief, he becomes a disillusioned figure who reflects on death and his place in the world. Without Tony’s or Christopher’s self-destructive vices, he eventually becomes the most human and sympathetic character.
Meaning of the line
If one interprets the line literally, it confirms that death approached Tony in the final scene. Life and death exist side by side – and death occurs in the blink of an eye. In Tony’s case: One moment he’s waiting for Meadow, the next he’s dead without noticing. Even if he wasn’t assassinated in that exact second, he would live under constant threat, especially after his closest allies are gone and the FBI threatens.
Paulie’s quote from Gregorian hymns adds an emotional clarity to the finale – whether it satisfies fans or not. The focus on “Dead Tony?” overshadows the intense emotion of the scene, accompanied by Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believin'”. Tony’s life collapses in real time: his captain, Carlo (Arthur J. Nascarella), is about to testify against him, and A.J.’s future is unclear. Dinner at Holsten’s becomes a moment of calm in the midst of the chaos.
In this gripping scene, written and directed by Chase, Tony says little while observing his surroundings. He seems to enjoy the normal, innocent moments around him. Even the depressive A.J. gives him unexpected comfort when he says, “Focus on the good times” – something Tony initially finds sarcastic. But when A.J. confirms that he is just repeating his father’s words, Tony replies, “Oh, that’s true, I suppose” and seems to take it to heart.
“The Sopranos” rarely promoted positive values, but it’s touching to see Tony accept his fate and choose to live as best he can until the inevitable happens. Although he was often annoyed by Paulie’s naïve outlook on life, he could have done worse than imitate his quiet acceptance. After all, Paulie is one of the few who is still alive – and whole.
Read on Popidol: New “Harry Potter” series on Max: Here are the new Harry, Hermione and Ron
